Knob Creek Single Barrel Bourbon Review [In Depth] The Whiskey Shelf (2024)

Knob Creek Single Barrel Bourbon

Knob Creek Single Barrel Bourbon Details

Knob Creek Single Barrel Overview

Knob Creek is part of Jim Beam’s small batch bourbon series (you can also consider the upgraded line) that spans Basil Hayden’s, Baker’s, Knob Creek, and Booker’s. I don’t know if you noticed, but SURPRISE! Knob Creek is owned by Jim Beam. The Knob Creek line itself is made up of a number of variations including the small batch, rye, smoked maple, and limited release 25th anniversary and 2001 editions.

Knob Creek Single Barrel Bourbon is particularly interesting because in today’s market offering a 9-year old nearly cask strength bourbon at the $40-50 price point is exceedingly uncommon. Many other bourbons with similar numbers (or no age statement) are easily $30-40 more expensive.

Comparable bourbons from companies such as Barrell and Michter’s cost more than double in part because they are sourced from somewhere else, so the distillery and the end bottler have to make money, adding an additional layer of markup.

The burning question then is – is Knob Creek Single Barrel Bourbon priced the way it is because Jim Beam Cut Corners, or because they made a great bourbon that just also happens to be a great value? Let’s find that out in this Knob Creek Single Barrel Bourbon review.

As an FYI, I bought and use these Glencairn glasses from Amazon for my reviews and comparisons (because they’re the best):Glencairn Crystal Whiskey Glass, Set of 6, Clear, 6 Pack.Full transparency, this is an affiliate link, so I may earn a commission if you buy this or something else from Amazon.

Jim Beam Lineup of Reviews

Knob Creek Single Barrel Smell

Knob Creek’s smell is a tale of two very different bourbons. It’s absurdly hot and unruly out of the freshly opened barrel, but significantly tamer after a few weeks. Give it some time to mellow before you pass your own.

Strong and spicy wood, pepper, allspice, and cinnamon explode out of the glass grasping for the first whiffs of air, with lightly nutty and minty following right behind. Moderate mashed corn, citrus, honey, and buttercream also battle for my attention, with underlying deep and dark caramel clinging to every sniff. Even over time, the alcohol remains potent and forceful but now plays a little nicer with the other scents.

Swirling lets Knob Creek Single Barrel Bourbon showcase more of the fruit. Now I get moderate notes of citrus, peach, dried cherries, and other fruits mixed with honey, brown sugar, and alcohol. There’s even a little bit of baked nuts and fuji apple sprinkled with cinnamon.

Going in a 3rd time, I get more honey with vanilla cream, citrus, and mashed corn, with cinnamon, nuts, peppermint, and a slight wisp of musty wood. Once the alcohol calms-down, there’s a wall of scents to explore.

Knob Creek Single Barrel Taste & Aftertaste

Knob Creek Single Barrel is a potent combination of caramel, honey, cinnamon, and allspice with enough vanilla, wood, and nuttiness to complement the sweetness. Minty rye and light sourdough bread are secondary. Even after mellowing it’s still quite hot, but it’s no longer overpoweringly distracting.

Chewing brings out more sweet caramel, brown sugar, orange, and butterscotch with moderate wood tannins, nuts, spice, and peppermint. More moderately strong cinnamon, cloves, pepper, and chocolate leap out at my tastebuds immediately after. There’s a nice depth of various flavors that swirl around waiting to be found, if you have the guts to handle it.

The mass of flavors fades quickly into light caramel, orange, and woody spice. Chewing amps it up, leaving the alcohol tingling my entire mouth with corn, honey, citrus, wood, nuts, and mint with just a sprinkle of cacao powder. The wood tannins are more pronounced, leaving a light spicy and bitter taste as well.

Knob Creek Single Barrel Bourbon Rating

Knob Creek Single Barrel is a disaster right out of the bottle. The alcohol initially destroys everything in its path, but subsides over time to let the richness, sweetness, and depth shine. I struggled between “Top Shelf” and “Mid Shelf+”, so I erred on the side of caution and gave it “Mid Shelf+”. Booker’s,Stagg Jr andParker’s Heritage 11are “Top Shelf” bourbons comparable to Knob Creek, albeit more developed and complex.

This further reinforces that Knob Creek Single Barrel is one of the best readily available “bang for your buck” bourbons (Weller Antique 107doesn’t count). Interestingly, this is not leaps and bounds better thanJim Beam Distiller’s Cut, more of a testament to the Jim Beam and less a knock on Knob Creek.

While I may not consider price for reviews, you and I certainly think about it when we buy. For the price and quality, it’s a great one to have on hand for any occasion, be it a large party or a small gathering with quality whiskey in hand. Since I haven’t yet had store-picked versions, I intend to explore them when I can find one unique enough to buy.

Knob Creek Single Barrel is a keeper and thankfully one that everyone has the opportunity to enjoy.

Meet the Author: Alex

Other Reviews